Hotel Beacon
Best for families and longer stays who want kitchenette-equipped rooms, easy access to grocery stores, and a residential Upper West Side location.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Beacon is a 4-star, family-friendly Upper West Side hotel with spacious rooms and kitchenettes for longer stays. Mandarin Oriental, New York is a 5-star luxury hotel at Columbus Circle with park-facing rooms, a full spa and an indoor pool—read this if you’re choosing between a residential UWS base and a Central Park–front luxury option.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart
Best for families and longer stays who want kitchenette-equipped rooms, easy access to grocery stores, and a residential Upper West Side location.
Best for travelers seeking luxury, spa and pool facilities, and Central Park- or Hudson-facing rooms near Columbus Circle.
When Hotel Beacon wins: Choose Hotel Beacon if you want larger, kitchenette-equipped rooms and suites for families or extended stays in a quieter Upper West Side neighborhood near museums and local shops.
When Mandarin Oriental, New York wins: Choose Mandarin Oriental for luxury finishes, an on-site full-service spa, an indoor pool, and direct proximity to Columbus Circle and formal Midtown access to Central Park views.
Bottom line: Hotel Beacon is the practical, residential choice for families and longer visits; Mandarin Oriental is the higher-end pick if you value spa services, an indoor pool, and a Columbus Circle/park-facing address.
| Category | Hotel Beacon | Mandarin Oriental, New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Residential, home-like hotel with kitchenette suites and a neighborhood feel | Upscale, luxury hotel with formal service and park/Hudson views |
| Location | 2130 Broadway (75th St) — Upper West Side, about a 10-minute walk to Central Park | 80 Columbus Circle at 60th Street — at Columbus Circle, immediate access to Central Park and Midtown |
| Size (guest rooms) | 278 guest rooms, including 139 suites | 244 guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All-ages; family-friendly | All-ages (not adults-only) |
| Pools | No on-site pool | Indoor pool (1) |
| Restaurants & bars | Viand Café (on-site) and Beacon Bar (bar currently closed for renovation) | 1 restaurant and 2 bars/lounges (MO Lounge and other outlets listed) |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa (hotel recommends nearby third‑party spas) | Full-service spa on site (reservations required) |
| Fitness | 24-hour, small fitness center focused on cardio equipment, accessible with room key | Fitness facilities / health club available |
| Known for | Kitchenette-equipped suites, residential Upper West Side location, family stays | Central Park/Hudson-facing luxury rooms, spa, and Midtown/Columbus Circle location |
| Check-in / Check-out | Check-in 3:00 PM; check-out 12:00 PM (noon) | |
Hotel Beacon sits on Broadway at 75th Street with a strong Upper West Side neighborhood feel.
Stay here for a quieter, residential base with easy park access and neighborhood amenities.
Mandarin Oriental is at Columbus Circle with immediate access to Central Park and Midtown landmarks.
Stay here for a central, park‑front location that keeps you close to Midtown attractions and formal hotel services.
Hotel Beacon’s rooms and suites are aimed at practical comfort for families and longer stays.
Choose Hotel Beacon when you want space and the ability to cook during your stay.
Mandarin Oriental’s rooms emphasize luxury, views, and premium bedding.
Pick Mandarin Oriental for higher-end finishes and rooms with park or river views.
Hotel Beacon offers neighborhood dining with an on-site American café and a lounge bar.
Expect familiar, casual dining and easy access to neighborhood eateries.
Mandarin Oriental provides formal dining and multiple hotel bars.
Choose Mandarin Oriental for in-hotel, service-focused dining and lounges.
Hotel Beacon does not have an on-site pool and recommends nearby options for swimming.
Hotel Beacon is not the choice if an on-site pool or spa is an important part of your stay.
Mandarin Oriental features a full-service spa and an indoor pool as core amenities.
Mandarin Oriental is the clear choice for in-hotel spa treatments and pool access.
Hotel Beacon caters to basic wellness needs and neighborhood nightlife.
Good for fitness-focused travelers who don’t need on-site spa services.
Mandarin Oriental focuses on higher-end wellness facilities and hotel nightlife.
Better for guests who want hotel-based wellness and refined evening outlets.
Hotel Beacon — kitchenettes in every room, many suites, and a residential Upper West Side location make longer family stays easier.
Mandarin Oriental — full-service spa and an indoor pool put wellness and relaxation on site.
Mandarin Oriental — multiple room types explicitly advertise Central Park views and premium park-facing options.
Hotel Beacon — adjacent grocery options, local restaurants, and easy subway access on Broadway.
Hotel Beacon — it's explicitly family-friendly, offers suites and kitchenettes, and has family rooms and nearby kid-friendly attractions.
Mandarin Oriental has an indoor pool and a full-service spa on site; Hotel Beacon does not have a pool or an on-site spa.
Mandarin Oriental is at Columbus Circle and is the closer option for Fifth Avenue, Rockefeller Center and Midtown theaters.
Yes. Both welcome guests year-round, but Mandarin Oriental’s indoor pool and spa might be more appealing in colder months while Hotel Beacon’s kitchenettes help on long stays.
Explore how Hotel Beacon stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·