Hotel Beacon
Best for families and longer stays who want in-room kitchenettes and a residential feel.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Beacon is a 4-star Upper West Side hotel with spacious rooms and in-room kitchenettes aimed at families and longer stays. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a 5-star, storied Upper East Side luxury property with old‑New York character for travelers seeking classic Manhattan refinement.
Updated · about 1.6 km apart
Best for families and longer stays who want in-room kitchenettes and a residential feel.
Best for travelers seeking classic, luxury Upper East Side service, history, and a full-service spa.
When Hotel Beacon wins: choose Hotel Beacon if you need extra space, a kitchenette in every room, easier family-friendly layout, and a more practical Upper West Side base for museum and park visits.
When The Carlyle wins: choose The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel if you want a small‑scale, five‑star Upper East Side experience, access to a full-service spa, Bemelman's Bar, and the hotel's long-standing reputation and service levels.
Bottom line: both hotels put you near Central Park and Manhattan museums, but they serve different needs — Hotel Beacon for practical, family-oriented stays; The Carlyle for traditional, high-end Manhattan luxury.
| Category | Hotel Beacon | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Residential, practical, family-friendly | Storied, formal, classic Upper East Side luxury |
| Location | Upper West Side, Broadway at 75th St (near Beacon Theatre and subway) | Upper East Side, 35 E 76th St (near Madison Avenue, close to Central Park) |
| Size / rooms | 278 guestrooms including 139 suites (24–25 floors) | 188 guestrooms |
| Stars / guest rating | 4-star, well suited to families (guest rating not provided here) | 5-star, guest rating 9.4 |
| Rooms: special feature | All rooms include a fully equipped kitchenette; many suites with sofa beds | Rooms feature minibars and espresso makers; several suite tiers and specialty suites |
| Pools / beach | No on-site pool | Not published (no on-site pool stated in supplier listing) |
| Restaurants & bars | Viand Café (American) plus the Beacon Bar (bar undergoing renovation) | Two restaurants including Bemelman's Bar and 24-hour room service |
| Wellness / fitness | 24-hour fitness center (small, cardio-focused); no on-site spa | Full-service spa and fitness facilities |
| Business & events | Multiple event rooms including Beacon Hall (≈2,000 sq ft) and smaller boardrooms; up to 150 guests | Smaller meeting footprint; 1 meeting room listed and concierge/business services |
| Known for | Kitchenettes and family-friendly suites on the Upper West Side | Historic, celebrity‑linked luxury and an old‑New York atmosphere |
Hotel Beacon sits on Broadway at 75th Street on the Upper West Side, steps from a subway stop and within easy walking distance of Central Park and the American Museum of Natural History.
A practical Upper West Side base for families and museum/park outings.
The Carlyle is on East 76th Street near Madison Avenue on the Upper East Side, a short walk to Central Park and the city's museum mile.
A refined Upper East Side location for museums, Madison Avenue shopping, and a quieter luxury address.
Hotel Beacon's rooms are aimed at longer stays and families, with kitchenettes in every unit and many suites with sofa beds.
Choose Hotel Beacon when in-room kitchen facilities and flexible sleeping arrangements matter.
The Carlyle's guest rooms and suites focus on traditional luxury touches and a range of suite categories.
The Carlyle is for travelers wanting classic luxury rooms and a variety of suite experiences.
Hotel Beacon offers Viand Café for American breakfast, lunch, and dinner and the Beacon Bar for light drinks and snacks.
Practical on-site dining with a neighborhood diner-style restaurant and bar.
The Carlyle offers two restaurants and the famous Bemelman's Bar plus round-the-clock room service.
A small set of refined dining venues and a signature bar suited to upscale hotel dining.
Hotel Beacon does not operate an on-site swimming pool and focuses instead on location and in-room appliances.
If on-site pool access is critical, Hotel Beacon is not the option; look nearby for swim facilities.
The Carlyle's supplier listing does not publish an on-site pool; the property's signature public amenities instead include a full-service spa.
The Carlyle prioritizes spa and concierge services rather than pool facilities in its listed amenities.
Hotel Beacon provides a 24-hour, key-access fitness center and neighborhood nightlife near the Beacon Theatre and Upper West Side restaurants.
A usable fitness option and local nightlife without on-site spa services.
The Carlyle includes a full-service spa and a notable, historic bar for evening drinks.
Choose The Carlyle for in-house spa treatments and classic hotel evening spots.
Hotel Beacon — in-room kitchenettes, family suites, and a residential feel make it practical for families and extended visits.
The Carlyle — storied reputation, suite variety, and a full-service spa suit travelers seeking traditional Manhattan luxury.
Hotel Beacon — close walking distance to Central Park and the American Museum of Natural History with practical room features.
The Carlyle — Bemelman's Bar and multiple on-site dining options provide a classic hotel dining scene.
Hotel Beacon — every room has a kitchenette, many suites include sofa beds, and the property is explicitly family-friendly.
The Carlyle lists a full-service spa in its supplier listing; a pool is not published in the listing.
The Carlyle is closer to the Met (the supplier listing notes it is within a short walk); Hotel Beacon requires a walk through or around Central Park.
No. Both properties are all-ages hotels and neither is a beachfront property.
Explore how Hotel Beacon stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·