Hotel Beacon
Best for families or travelers who want roomy suites with fully equipped kitchenettes and an Upper West Side residential feel.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Beacon is a 4-star Upper West Side hotel known for spacious rooms and fully equipped kitchenettes, good for families or longer Manhattan stays. The Peninsula New York is a 5-star Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with classic service, a full spa and indoor pool—read this if you’re choosing between a residential, suite-style stay and a Fifth Avenue luxury experience.
Updated · about 2.0 km apart
Best for families or travelers who want roomy suites with fully equipped kitchenettes and an Upper West Side residential feel.
Best for travelers who want classic Fifth Avenue luxury with a full-service spa, indoor pool, and high-profile Midtown location.
When Hotel Beacon wins: choose Hotel Beacon if you need space, family-friendly rooms and a kitchenette to prepare snacks or light meals—it’s practical for multi-night stays and families who want easy access to Central Park and museum neighborhoods.
When The Peninsula New York wins: pick The Peninsula for a central Midtown address near MoMA and 5th Avenue shopping, a formal luxury service model, an indoor pool and full-service spa, and a higher-end hotel environment.
Bottom line: Hotel Beacon is the practical, apartment-style Upper West Side option for families and longer stays; The Peninsula New York is the classic Fifth Avenue luxury pick for travelers prioritizing spa, pool and a central Midtown location.
| Category | Hotel Beacon | The Peninsula New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Residential, home-like Upper West Side hotel with kitchenette rooms | Beaux-Arts Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with formal service |
| Location | 2130 Broadway (75th St) — Upper West Side, near Central Park and museums | 700 Fifth Avenue at 55th Street — Midtown, steps from 5th Avenue and MoMA |
| Size (guest rooms) | 278 guestrooms, including 139 suites | 219 guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages — family-friendly | |
| Pools | No on-site swimming pool | Indoor pool available |
| Restaurants & bars | Viand Café (American) plus Beacon Bar (lounge) — Beacon Bar currently listed as under renovation | Clement Restaurant (American), 3 bars/lounges and 24-hour room service |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa (hotel recommends nearby, third-party options); 24-hour fitness center | Full-service spa, sauna and 24-hour health club |
| Known for | Large suites with kitchenettes and proximity to Central Park and museums | Classic Fifth Avenue address, formal luxury amenities and recognized Peninsula brand |
| Free WiFi | Complimentary Wi‑Fi and wired internet | |
Hotel Beacon sits on Broadway at 75th Street, a residential Upper West Side block across from Fairway and close to Central Park and local museums.
Choose Hotel Beacon for a residential neighborhood feel with easy park and museum access.
The Peninsula New York is on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, a central Midtown location near MoMA, Rockefeller Center and high-end shopping.
Choose The Peninsula for a Midtown address within walking distance of major Midtown sights and shopping.
Hotel Beacon’s rooms emphasize space and self-catering with fully equipped kitchenettes in every room.
If you want space and a kitchenette, Hotel Beacon is designed for that need.
The Peninsula New York offers classic Fifth Avenue luxury rooms and suites with premium bedding and in-room services.
The Peninsula fits travelers who prioritize traditional luxury appointments and in-room service.
Hotel Beacon’s on-site dining centers on Viand Café, a longtime local American cafe, plus a lounge bar.
Hotel Beacon offers a dependable neighborhood café and easy access to local dining.
The Peninsula features Clement Restaurant for American dining, 3 bars/lounges and 24-hour room service.
The Peninsula provides more in-house dining and bar variety typical of a full-service luxury hotel.
Hotel Beacon does not have an on-site swimming pool and points guests to nearby public options if needed.
Don’t expect a pool at Hotel Beacon—it’s focused on roomy accommodations and neighborhood access.
The Peninsula New York includes an indoor pool as part of its wellness offerings alongside a full-service spa.
If an on-site pool and a hotel-operated spa matter, The Peninsula provides those facilities.
Hotel Beacon’s wellness offering is a small 24-hour fitness center; nightlife is mainly neighborhood bars and the Beacon Theatre next door.
Hotel Beacon suits guests who want basic fitness access and neighborhood culture rather than hotel nightlife or spa treatments.
The Peninsula blends a full-service spa and 24-hour health club with easy access to Midtown’s dining and nightlife.
For in-house wellness and easy access to high-end Midtown nightlife, The Peninsula is the stronger option.
Hotel Beacon — suites with kitchenettes and larger layouts make it practical for families and extended visits.
The Peninsula New York — steps from 5th Avenue and MoMA, ideal for shoppers and Midtown sightseeing.
The Peninsula New York — offers a full-service spa, sauna and an indoor pool.
Hotel Beacon — more suites and kitchenette-equipped rooms per guest make it better value if space matters.
Hotel Beacon — it is explicitly family-friendly, offers suites with kitchenettes and sofa beds, and has easy access to family attractions like Central Park and the American Museum of Natural History.
The Peninsula New York — it operates a full-service spa, sauna and an indoor pool. Hotel Beacon does not have an on-site spa or pool.
The Peninsula New York — located on Fifth Avenue at 55th Street, it’s within a short walk of MoMA, Rockefeller Center and 5th Avenue stores.
Yes — both Hotel Beacon and The Peninsula New York list complimentary wired and/or wireless internet access for guests.
Explore how Hotel Beacon stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·