Hotel Beacon
Best for families and longer stays who want kitchenettes, larger suites and an Upper West Side base near museums and parks.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Beacon is a practical, residential-style Upper West Side hotel with roomy kitchenette suites for families and longer stays; read this if you want space, self-catering and a convenient uptown location. The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel is a refined Upper East Side, 5-star property with a full-service spa and Italian dining; read this if you want polished, residential luxury close to Central Park and the Met.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart
Best for families and longer stays who want kitchenettes, larger suites and an Upper West Side base near museums and parks.
Best for travelers seeking a small, luxury Upper East Side hotel with a spa, Italian restaurant and upscale service close to the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
When Hotel Beacon wins: choose Hotel Beacon if you need suite-style accommodations with a full kitchenette, more space for families or longer stays, practical meeting/event rooms, and a direct Upper West Side feel next to the Beacon Theatre.
When The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel wins: choose The Surrey when you want a small 5-star experience — Frette sheets, in‑house spa services and Casa Tua Italian dining — and prefer the museum-and-Madison‑Avenue side of Central Park.
Bottom line: both are uptown alternatives to Midtown Manhattan; pick Hotel Beacon for utility, suite space and family-friendly features, and pick The Surrey for a higher-end, service-focused Upper East Side stay.
| Category | Hotel Beacon | The Surrey A Corinthia Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Practical, residential Upper West Side; roomy kitchenette suites | Refined, residential Upper East Side luxury with boutique scale |
| Location | 2130 Broadway (75th St), Upper West Side — near Central Park West, AMNH and Beacon Theatre | 20 East 76th Street, Upper East Side — a short walk to Central Park and Metropolitan Museum of Art |
| Size | 278 guestrooms (139 suites), 24 stories | 100 guestrooms |
| Audience / age policy | All ages welcome; family-friendly | |
| Pools | No on-site pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Viand Café (American; breakfast/lunch/dinner) and Beacon Bar (lounge; currently under renovation) | Casa Tua (Italian restaurant) and a bar/lounge; 24-hour room service available |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; 24-hour fitness center (small, cardio-focused) | Full-service spa with massage and facial treatments; 24-hour fitness facilities |
| Known for | Kitchenette-equipped suites, family-friendly layout, Beacon Theatre adjacency | Corinthia luxury branding, proximity to Met and Madison Avenue, Frette linens |
| Meeting & event space | Multiple meeting rooms (Beacon Hall ~2,000 sq ft; total ~3,300 sq ft) and small-to-mid event capacities | Smaller-scale luxury hotel event capacities (meeting rooms published in supplier listing are limited); concierge/white-glove service |
| Wi‑Fi | Complimentary Wi‑Fi and wired internet | |
Hotel Beacon sits on Broadway at 75th Street, steps from the Beacon Theatre and a short walk to Central Park and the American Museum of Natural History.
A practical Upper West Side home base for families and museum-goers.
The Surrey is on East 76th Street — an Upper East Side address minutes from Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
A compact, upscale Upper East Side location for culture and shopping.
Hotel Beacon emphasizes larger rooms and suites with full kitchenettes, designed for families and longer stays.
Choose Hotel Beacon if space, kitchen facilities and suite variety matter.
The Surrey offers about 100 guestrooms with luxury touches like Frette sheets and designer toiletries.
The Surrey is for travelers who prioritize classic 5-star finishes and smaller hotel scale.
Hotel Beacon's on-site dining is centered on Viand Café — a long-running American café serving all-day menus.
Practical, casual dining with the option to self-cater from the kitchenette.
The Surrey lists Casa Tua as its on-site restaurant and a bar/lounge; room service is available 24 hours.
The Surrey leans toward formal dining and white-glove service versus casual café meals.
Hotel Beacon does not operate an on-site swimming pool or a hotel-run spa.
Expect a practical fitness offering but no pool or on-site spa services.
The Surrey features a full-service spa alongside 24-hour fitness facilities, per the supplier listing.
Pick The Surrey if you value an on-property spa and dedicated wellness services.
Hotel Beacon focuses on everyday conveniences and neighborhood nightlife near the Beacon Theatre.
Good for event-goers and practical nightlife access rather than in‑hotel wellness.
The Surrey offers in‑house spa services and a quieter Upper East Side evening scene focused on dining and galleries.
Better for travelers looking for hotel-based wellness and refined evening options.
Hotel Beacon — every room has a fully equipped kitchenette and many larger suites for families or longer visits.
The Surrey — full-service spa, 24-hour fitness and Corinthia luxury positioning suit guests seeking upscale in‑hotel wellness.
The Surrey — a short walk to the Metropolitan Museum of Art and Madison Avenue galleries.
Hotel Beacon — adjacent to the Beacon Theatre and near the Broadway/ Lincoln Center areas; robust event spaces on-site.
Hotel Beacon — it advertises family rooms, larger suites, kitchenettes and a generally family-friendly layout.
The Surrey has a full-service spa on-site; Hotel Beacon does not operate an on-site spa or pool.
Yes. Hotel Beacon and The Surrey are both within a short walk of Central Park on opposite sides (Upper West vs Upper East).
Hotel Beacon does not offer on-site parking (independent garages nearby). The Surrey's supplier listing notes covered/valet parking (surcharge).
Explore how Hotel Beacon stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·