Hotel Beacon
Best for families or longer stays who want kitchenettes, larger suites, and an Upper West Side neighborhood base.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hotel Beacon is a 4-star Upper West Side property with spacious kitchenette suites and a family-friendly, residential feel — good for travelers who want room to spread out near Central Park and museums. The New York EDITION is a 5-star lifestyle luxury hotel by Madison Square Park — read this if you’re comparing fashionable downtown–Midtown boutique luxury with a well-known brand name.
Updated · about 4.3 km apart
Best for families or longer stays who want kitchenettes, larger suites, and an Upper West Side neighborhood base.
Best for travelers who want a centrally located, branded luxury stay and on-site dining and lounge options near Flatiron and Madison Square Park.
When Hotel Beacon wins: choose Hotel Beacon if you need suite-style rooms with fully equipped kitchenettes, want an Upper West Side location near Central Park and museums, or are traveling with family and need space and practical amenities.
When The New York EDITION wins: choose The New York EDITION if you want a polished 5-star lifestyle hotel in the Flatiron/Madison Park area with signature dining (The Clocktower), bars, and on-site spa services.
Bottom line: Hotel Beacon is practical and residential — better for families or longer stays — while The New York EDITION is a downtown luxury choice for travelers focused on fashionably positioned hotels, food & drink, and branded luxury services.
| Category | Hotel Beacon | The New York EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Residential, suite-focused Upper West Side hotel | Lifestyle luxury hotel with brand recognition |
| Location | Upper West Side, near Central Park, museums, Beacon Theatre | Flatiron / Madison Square Park, steps from Madison Square Park and Flatiron Building |
| Size (rooms) | 278 guest rooms, including 139 suites | 271 guest rooms |
| Ages / audience | All-ages, family-friendly | All-ages (not adults-only) |
| Pools | No on-site pool | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Viand Café (breakfast/lunch/dinner) and Beacon Bar (bar; currently renovating) | The Clocktower (restaurant) plus 2 bars/lounges and 24-hour room service |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa; recommends local off-site spas; 24-hour fitness center in basement | Spa services on site plus fitness facilities and 24-hour front desk |
| Known for | Kitchenette-equipped suites and proximity to parks/museums | Madison Square Park location, EDITION brand, signature dining and lounges |
| Meeting & events | Multiple meeting rooms and event spaces (Beacon Hall, Amsterdam Room, Broadway Room); up to ~150 guests | Conference space (2100 ft²) and 5 meeting rooms for events |
| Fees & extras | No facility/resort fee advertised; breakfast available for a surcharge; no on-site parking | Destination fee (USD 51.64/night) plus optional fees (valet, pet fee, breakfast surcharge) |
Hotel Beacon sits at Broadway and 75th Street on the Upper West Side, close to parks and museums.
Choose Hotel Beacon if you want easy access to Central Park, museum visits, and a quieter residential neighborhood.
The New York EDITION is located at 5 Madison Avenue, steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building.
Choose The New York EDITION for a central Flatiron/Madison Park location and easy access to downtown and Midtown sights.
Hotel Beacon emphasizes suite-style accommodations with kitchenettes in every room.
Hotel Beacon is the better pick if you value space and in-room cooking/prep facilities.
The New York EDITION offers 271 air-conditioned rooms with typical 5-star room amenities.
The New York EDITION suits travelers who want polished 5-star rooms and branded luxury details rather than kitchenette suites.
Hotel Beacon’s on-site dining centers on Viand Café, plus a lounge bar linking to the Beacon Theatre.
Pick Hotel Beacon for reliable all-day café dining and neighborhood restaurant access.
The New York EDITION emphasizes a signature on-site restaurant and lounge experience.
Choose The New York EDITION if on-site upscale dining and bar/lounge options matter to your stay.
Hotel Beacon does not operate an on-site swimming pool.
Hotel Beacon is not for guests who need an on-site pool; it prioritizes practical apartment-style rooms and location.
The New York EDITION lists spa services on site and multiple food & drink outlets.
The New York EDITION is the better option for travelers who want on-site spa services and branded hospitality spaces; pool availability is not published.
Hotel Beacon offers a 24-hour fitness center and is near Upper West Side nightlife and family-friendly evening options.
Hotel Beacon is tuned to guests who want a reliable fitness option and quieter, neighborhood evenings.
The New York EDITION has fitness facilities, bars/lounges, and a downtown nightlife footprint.
The New York EDITION fits travelers seeking branded hotel nightlife and easy access to downtown restaurants and bars.
Hotel Beacon — all rooms include fully equipped kitchenettes and many suites with sofa beds, which helps families and guests staying longer.
The New York EDITION — a 5-star lifestyle hotel with The Clocktower restaurant, multiple bars, and on-site spa services.
Hotel Beacon — multiple meeting rooms and event spaces, plus space for up to ~150 guests in a residential neighborhood setting.
The New York EDITION — steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building, convenient for downtown and Midtown walking routes.
Hotel Beacon — it’s marketed family-friendly, offers suites with kitchenettes and sofa beds, and is close to Central Park and museums.
The New York EDITION — it’s a 5-star lifestyle property with The Clocktower restaurant, bars, and on-site spa services.
Hotel Beacon does not have an on-site pool. The New York EDITION’s supplier listing does not publish pool availability.
No — both properties are all-ages and neither is listed as adults-only.
Explore how Hotel Beacon stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·